When it comes to public health guidance, doctors should always be trusted over politicians.
Under Senate Bill 48, political agendas could override orders by health officers during pandemic-like conditions.
The proposed bill, authored by Sens. James Tomes, Blake Doriot, and Ron Alting, would require city and county health departments to get approval from their government executives to enforce orders relating to communicable diseases lasting more than 14 days. It would also limit health departments’ abilities to fine businesses failing to comply with their rules, and establish a cause of action for an individual to file a court action concerning certain enforcement actions taken by a local health officer or local health board.
It makes sense to question how much authority health departments should have over the public during health emergencies, but giving politicians more power over our health experts isn’t the best answer.
During the COVID-19 pandemic, politics have negatively impacted public health in the United States.
One example could be seen in public mask compliance. For months, many individuals aligned with their local, state, and federal officials in defying the recommendation to wear face coverings in public despite its proven ability to slow the virus’ spread. Unfortunately, it took a change in tone politically for many to adhere to the rule.
Additionally, it’s dangerous to encourage lawsuits against health departments if they enforce a rule during a pandemic. Such a policy would hinder the ability for the department to do its job.
Many health departments are already working with their elected officials to help establish rules in Indiana. In Bartholomew County, the COVID-19 Task Force has worked in conjunction with Dr. Brian Niedbalski, county health officer, in communicating concerns and developing guidelines during the COVID-19 crisis.
Under the current rules, businesses receive multiple warnings before a fine or closure is even considered. Local businesses have largely complied, which in turn has created a safer environment for them to remain open.
Public health emergencies don’t occur frequently, but when they do we should turn to health experts for answers. Adding another layer of government would only complicate the issue.
Sent comments to editorial@therepublic.com.
